I have a friend who is going through a particularly nasty divorce. So far, it has all the trappings of a Lifetime Movie starring Tracey Gold and Dean Cain, including the ex-spouse leading a “double-life”, the “bitter custody battle”, and the trespassed-upon woman who finally “finds her strength”. I just hope it ends without the “attempted kidnapping and daring rescue” of the child, because her life is not a movie. It is serious stuff, and when serious stuff happens in Real Life, you don’t always get that clean, yet bittersweet ending. Real Life is so much messier and, sometimes even more ludicrous than a Lifetime Movie. It’s like the Real Life script-writers aren’t even trying to entertain us! I do take solace in the fact that Real Life script-writers tend mostly to shy away from the overtly clichéd dramatic stuff, so plot twists, like kidnapping, are relatively rare. But sublimely happy endings are rare, too, and that, I think, is what makes a Lifetime Movie so much better than the crap Real Life comes up with. It’s just more hopeful and clear cut. Good girls win, bad guys lose – A nice, feminist fantasy which, if those Real Life writers penned it, I would vociferously rail against, but that’s another blog. Lifetime can get away with anything, though.
So, Andy Rooney died this weekend, and because he was a fairly famous guy, I read a few articles out there about him. In one of them, he is quoted as admitting that he was also a fairly vindictive guy. Apparently, he was one who actually did sweat the small stuff. He said, “Even in petty things in my life I tend to strike back. It’s a lot more pleasurable a sensation than feeling threatened.” Omigod, isn’t it, though?! In the short run, vengeance does smell like justice being served on a hot platter. It even looks tender and juicy and delectable. But, despite what you may have been told, here’s really why they came up with that whole saying about it best being served cold: In the long run, vengeance doesn’t taste anything at all like justice. It doesn’t even call for the same ingredients. Because, if justice is a juicy grass-fed steak that took months and months to age, and was grilled slowly to perfection; well then, vengeance is just a genetically-modified, microwaved soy-justice burger slapped between two slices of Wonder Bread. The quality is lower, you never really feel you’ve gotten enough, and the unseen side effects to those who consume it are toxic and cumulative.
It has been said about me by many who know me well, and some who don’t, that I am quite immature for my age…no matter what my age at any given time. Hell, I readily admit I am a 16-year-old trapped in a 46-year-old (and getting older by the minute) body. So it will come as no surprise to anyone that I have often punctuated an argument, justified my actions, or qualified my opinion with the simple phrase: You started it. At least I am woman enough to admit it and say it out loud, because come on and tell me you haven’t thought it! Then try to think of one disagreement, one fist fight, one gangland slaying, one political skirmish, or one war (even the Cold one), that could not be boiled down to each side, at their core, seeking vengeance against the other side because….
They started it.
I am certainly not some tree-hugging, peace-at–any-cost hippie. I understand that you have to stand up for yourself; that you, more often than not, have to fight for your rights; and that you may find yourself in a situation that has escalated before you know it, and you have no other way to extricate yourself from it but to keep fighting the good fight. My friend’s divorce did not turn ugly on a dime one day. It escalated incrementally from a healthy place of wanting to just be out of a bad situation that was making her unhappy, to a place of digging in and not giving into his ever more outlandish demands. I get this, and I’m not judging her for it. Her ex DID start it!
I have been reading a lot about Native American culture this past month, and no one has a better claim to the “They Started It” defense than those people do. I mean, talk about just sitting around minding your own business. I don’t consider myself any kind of an expert in Native American history by any stretch, but I do know that many of the tribes gave as good as they got…or better. They could be ruthless, and perhaps that ruthlessness upped the ante, giving the white settlers a fresh, “Ok, we did that thing over there, but hey, they started THIS THING HERE!” mentality. But what is a Native American whose home and very way of life is being taken from him to do? When it comes to vengeance, I’m not sure there is such a thing as “overkill” when it finally dawns on you that there will be no justice for you and yours; and that you, and everyone who looks like you, are systematically being wiped off the face of the Turtle Shell. In the end though, ruthless or not, the Native Americans never had a chance. Every tribe’s days were numbered, really, from the minute Columbus set sail. While that seems clear to us now, and maybe it was even clear to the white settlers then, it certainly was not readily apparent to most of the tribes in the early days of this nation’s history. So, they fought back. Because those white guys started it. None of us knows what would have happened if they had not fought back so hard. Maybe more would be around today to pass down a different tale of subjugation and the wiping out of merely their culture. Or, maybe none would be around at all. Let’s ask all six of the Jews left living in Krakow today how not fighting back worked out.
All I know is, this notion of vengeance surely must be deeply-rooted in all of us. We all walk around knowing on some level that our actions are justified simply because the other guy started it. I myself have gone through a divorce that, at the time, I thought was the very definition of the word “amicable”. There was no battle for custody. There was no battle at all. Two reasonable people with no axes to grind on either side simply dissolved their union and went their separate ways, coming together to co-parent when the need arose. Doesn’t that sound lovely? It almost makes divorce sound desirable. But I have a penchant for idealism that can be irksome at times to those living in the real world. Like I really think I AM living in a Lifetime movie. So, that was probably just how I saw it. For sure, I did not see myself as the winner and my ex as the loser. If anything, I actually saw us both as losers. We lost a family unit, we lost a history, we maybe even lost a bit of ourselves. But I deluded myself into thinking we’d retained a friendship, and I was just conceited enough to feel proud of my part in that (and to believe that Yasmine Bleeth will play me in the Lifetime movie of the whole incident). Look how mature I am! Look at what a reasonable adult I am! I had no idea that deep down, my ex was still harboring some serious bitterness, and had a running tally in his head of things that “I started”, some going all the way back to when we dated. It never occurred to me that there really was a war going on underneath the calm exterior of our “friendship”. Like an ignorant (and arrogant) white settler, I just took over territory I believed was mine by right of my own personal “manifest destiny”. And like Quannah Parker, my ex went quietly into the hills and patiently waited for the opportune moment to make his last stand against me. The details are still in dispute, but I believe he won and it is my turn to retaliate. I have pulled the arrow out of my shoulder, and I guess I should go back for his scalp, but I think I can see the writing on the wall now. Let him go. No one is going to win this thing anyway. I guess I took something he thought was his, so he took something I thought was mine. I’m sure he sees this in a completely different light, but I guarantee you this: He thinks I started it, and I think he started it. He believes he lost, I believe I lost. The only thing we would agree on is that we are not even. But we are done, and I can choose to not retaliate further. How’s that for maturity? Or maybe this blog is my retaliation, and I’m just as immature as I ever was. In the movie, a little tear runs down Yasmine’s cheek as the credits roll.
So yeah, payback is a bitch, but it turns out, one that is endlessly chasing it’s own tail. It always looks pretty badass when you come upon it, and it serves the intended purpose…at first. Divorces are finally granted, wounds are finally treated, land is finally divided, peace is finally made. But most of the time, that is usually where Justice finally walked in, trained the people and rehabilitated the Vengeance Bitch. Until the damn thing got out of the cage again and reminded someone, or more likely, stirred the rancor of someone who never forgot in the first place, and spurred them on to remind the rest of us, of what they lost the last time around. And it winds up again, like it never ended the quest for its own tail in the first place. Believe me, when history books are written in the next millennium, WWI and WWII will just be one big WW with a 15-minute smoke-break in the middle. The pain of being wronged can go back years, even passed down to future generations through the centuries. Hell, it can go back millennia for some, and exacting revenge is the easiest and broadest answer to those pressing life problems, big and small. Let’s be real: Someone, somewhere at some time is always starting up some shit. Sometimes it’s you, sometimes it’s me. But does someone always have to feel the need to get even? Umm, yeah, someone always does. Sometimes it’s you, sometimes it’s me. We turn a blind eye to the self-perpetuating nature of vengeance, I think because in some respects we are ALL immature kids out on the playground of life, and because Andy Rooney is right, retaliation just feels better than being threatened. So, there you have it: It’s justifiable, it’s gratifying, and sometimes it really IS the other guy who started it.
So, until the Real Life script-writers come up with a plot twist that renders payback a toothless bitch, I’m just going to watch me a little old-school Meredith Baxter on Lifetime, where all the bad guys go to jail or die horrible, yet bloodless deaths, and all the good women get full custody of their adorable sons, and marry the handsome and brave detective that rescued them.